What’s hot/What’s not: 2007 Year End Spectacular…
Ok, here is the list of the hottest and not hottest cable news related stories for 2007. I hope I haven’t overlooked anything. These are not prioritized by the way…
What’s hot for 2007:
The Fall and Rise of Don Imus - Don Imus’ controversial comments about the Rutgers’ women’s basketball team, either rightly or wrongly, eventually led to his ouster from MSNBC TV and CBS Radio. Imus stayed under the radar for the next several months before re-surfacing with a new radio and TV gig.
FBN launches - Rupert Murdoch’s long speculated about stab at a business news channel finally came to fruition this fall with the launch of the Fox Business Network. Which leads nicely to…
Defections and defectors - One of the first battles between the new upstart FBN and the established battle tested veteran CNBC was over talent, with FBN drawing first blood. This first manifested itself with a ridiculous battle over a “business news talent minnow” named Eric Bolling for which CNBC lawyered up big time with some high priced Manhattan attorneys to keep Bolling sitting on the sidelines and off FBN’s air until the last possible second. This however came on the heels of the news that CNBC’s “non-minnow” Liz Claman had decided to jump to FBN when her contract expired with CNBC (co-incidentally it expired within days of FBN’s launch).
So long Secaucus - MSNBC finally moved in to 30 Rock with a slick news studio. And with that came…
Another change at the MSNBC top - Dan Abrams stepped down as MSNBC GM to host his nightly program and NBC News VP Phil Griffin assumed a greater role in overseeing the network.
Campbell Brown joins CNN - In an interesting play which may be dissected in the years to come depending on how it all unfolds in 2008, Campbell Brown jumped from NBC to CNN.
Keith Olbermann renews with MSNBC - Despite rumors circulating that CNN wanted to entice Keith Olbermann, only to have that reportedly quashed by Jim Walton before an offer could be made, Keith Olbermann re-signed with MSNBC to a lucrative deal which spread Olbermann’s visibility beyond the cable network. Which leads me to…
The death and rebirth of Olbermann Watch - Seeing the writing on the wall, so to speak, Olbermann Watch decided to pack it in. But then the critics of Olbermann Watch danced a little too hard on its grave so it was brought back, much to the consternation of all.
Olbermann admits leftward slant on Countdown - You could see him taking tentative steps towards outting his program as leftward leaning but in 2007 Keith Olbermann finally admitted that Countdown does tilt left.
Erin Burnett - I’m still not sure exactly what triggered it but Erin Burnett emerged in 2007 as a successor to, and chief rival of, Maria Bartiromo. Whether there is any actual rivalry or not is conjecture, but that didn’t stop the press from playing up that angle.
FNC commits to Shepard Smith big time - With his mega mega uber deal with FNC, rumored to be around 7 million a year, Shepard Smith enters the big money league of broadcast network news anchors and FNC makes a huge commitment to a talent it could ill-afford to lose.
Kiran Chetry jumps ship (or was pushed?) - Depending on which story you believe, Kiran Chetry (and her agent) made herself persona non grata at FNC or FNC was the villian and Chetry was the victim. Whichever the case, the result was Chetry was on CNN’s air within 24 hours and on American Morning within weeks.
American Morning gets overhauled - For all intents and purposes, CNN President Jonathan Klein blew up American Morning and started over. American Morning was still the program’s name but at the end of 2007 there was little resemblence to the show that started 2007. Carol Costello? Gone to The Situation Room. Soledad O’Brien and Miles O’Brien? Taken off the program. Story selection? A move towards emphasizing hard news and more of it.
The Situation Room and Lou Dobbs Tonight flip positions - The 7pm ET edition of The Situation Room changed places with the 6pm Lou Dobbs Tonight. This gave CNN three uninterrupted hours of The Situation Room and put Dobbs up against The Fox Report.
Rick Sanchez’s star rises - He was called in to just pinch hit at 8pm until Brown could take over but he exceeded expectations for CNN. Some nights Out in the Open generates more email feedback than either Jack Cafferty or Lou Dobbs. The question heading into 2008 is what does CNN do with its star on the rise?
Super Tuesday on MSNBC - When it was announced I thought it was a stretch. I didn’t believe MSNBC could sustain coverage like that for such an extended period and keep it interesting and fresh. I was wrong. It may not have shot up in the ratings but it did manage to assosciate MSNBC and politics.
What’s not for 2007:
Cuts to NBC News - 2007 ended on a dour note for MSNBC. After having barely had time to settle in to its new 30 Rock digs, MSNBC was rocked by a bunch of cuts that came down to NBC News. Morale plummetted and rumors circulated about people looking for new stable places to work.
Paula Zahn Now gets euthanized - It was long overdue but watching the decline and fall of Paula Zahn Now at CNN and how that program was left twisting in the wind for years left a bad taste in a lot of people’s mouths. The definitive takedown on the Paula Zahn mess remains Eat The Press’ Rachel Sklar’s devastating must-read critique on the matter.
Chetry and Roberts replace O’Brien and O’Brien on American Morning - The main excuse given for replacing Soledad O’Brien and Miles O’Brien on American Morning was a lack of chemistry. That may or may not be accurate. I thought Miles was a good fit for the show but I didn’t see a lot of chemistry between the two O’Briens. However it became immediately apparent to me from day one that CNN had repeated the mistake with Kiran Chetry and John Roberts. Roberts will always be a hard news primetime type of personality to me and I can’t get used to him on the mornings, even with the renewed emphasis on hard news. And the chemistry between the Roberts and Chetry pairing is worse than what CNN had before with the two O’Briens.
Maria Bartiromo - I’m not sure her star really fell much in 2007, the Todd Thompson incident non-withstanding. But in the court of public opinion and that of the media, it did. Between Citigroup and the surge in popularity of Erin Burnett, Bartiromo was no longer viewed as the unquestioned star of CNBC, even though Maria did trademark “Money Honey”. Though Burnett has not achieved Bartiromo’s penetration outside of CNBC (Business Week columns, her own NBC syndicated program, etc…) so while the press has made a lot of hay about Bartiromo’s star allegedly setting as Burnett’s rose, this competition, if it can be called that, is still far from settled.
The rise of Courtney Friel - Maybe all the criticism is unfair and unjustified and maybe it isn’t. But I have never seen such universal animosity directed towards someone…and by the very people who watch FNC the most. I wasn’t going to mention her at all but after seeing half the comments on the submissions list specifically mention her and all by FNC fans, I couldn’t ignore it. It’s almost as if someone at FNC is pushing Friel out on the viewing public with a damn the torpedoes mentality; as in, “You’re wrong and I’ll show you. I will make her a network news anchor and you will watch and you will learn. And you will see that we were right in choosing her.” And yet FNC continues to send out confusing signals regarding Friel because she’s still doing Lips & Ears segments. And whatever happened to the political blogging? I haven’t heard a whit about it since the announcement.
Tucker Carlson - The story took shape from rumors and by reading between the lines some of the public statements by MSNBC execs, that Carlson’s MSNBC show is on the chopping block. Some stories say it’s already been axed and it’s just a matter of finding something to replace it with.
AC 360 loses an hour - It actually began early in the summer but it wasn’t until after Labor Day that CNN publicly acknowledged that the two hour Anderson Cooper 360 was going to be mostly one hour live going forward. This leaves HLN’s Showbiz Tonight as the only original topical programming on cable news at 11 pm.
We’re not concerned - In what I would argue to be the PR blunder of the year, all the feigned indifference by NBC and CNBC to FBN prior to launch was the gift that has kept on giving…to FBN! Every time CNBC has done anything that could even remotely show interest in what FBN is up to, and there have been plenty of examples including a user survey of business talent including FBN’s, FBN has thrown that now infamous quip about not being concerned back in CNBC’s face. Over and over and over again.
Tammy Haddad - First she loses her position as EP of Hardball, then she is eased out at quits NBC as the VP of Washington for MSNBC.
Base pandering by the Democratic candidates against FNC - It was all BS. We all knew it was BS. They did it to pander to their base. But now that it’s crunch time look who is showing up on FNC in the closing days…
Questions about MSNBC’s focus and branding - I heard weeks after the fact that this Jossip leak caused a huge uproar inside 30 Rock. Maybe it hit a little too close to home? And then there was this little noticed shot by Jonathan Klein at MSNBC which basically called them out publicly on their over-emphasis on crime blocks and abandoning news…
“When they do that, they’re really competing with Court TV,” Mr. Klein later told NYTV in an interview in his office overlooking Columbus Circle. “They’re saying, in effect, we give up trying to cover the news in any meaningful way. It enhances our brand. We’re the last man standing in terms of covering the news. We love that.”
Overindulging in trash TV - Anna Nicole’s death, the custody battle that followed, Paris Hilton, Britney Spears, Lindsay Lohan, Nicole Richie, O.J. Simpson. If there was one universal low point in cable news it was the overabundance of pandering to the tawdry.



“When they do that, they’re really competing with Court TV,” Mr. Klein later told NYTV in an interview in his office overlooking Columbus Circle. “They’re saying, in effect, we give up trying to cover the news in any meaningful way. It enhances our brand. We’re the last man standing in terms of covering the news. We love that.”
Huh, Klein took off the second hour of 360 then takes a pot shot at MSNBC over the doc block which beats 360 sometimes in the ratings?
Huh?
Comment by Anonymous — December 31, 2007 @ 12:22 pm
Bravo, Spud! Well done.
I’m going to go sing, “Memories” now… and think about 2007.
Comment by ImNotBlue — December 31, 2007 @ 12:38 pm
Nice write-up.
Comment by Lurker — December 31, 2007 @ 12:48 pm
Well done Spud! Also, if anyone wants a reminder of Zahn’s last day at CNN, click the link on my name, still amazing to look back at that and remember watching it that night, seemed like she was getting pushed out, which we all already know.
Anyhow, once again, great job on the list!
Comment by Chris — December 31, 2007 @ 12:51 pm
Excellent list!
Comment by myview — December 31, 2007 @ 1:17 pm
Spud: Agreed, a good list and analysis.
Two comments:
I’m surprised to see Eric Bolling’s so-called defection so close to the top of your list. He was/is basically a non-entity on both networks.
And assuming that amused is a male, I find it interesting that most of the sharpest criticism of Courtney Friel on ICN comes from other women.
Comment by Ira — December 31, 2007 @ 1:46 pm
Ira, I noted right at the top that the list isn’t prioritized.
Comment by Spud — December 31, 2007 @ 2:21 pm
Great work, Spud.
Comment by Aaron — December 31, 2007 @ 2:32 pm
Spud you did a fine job. But failed to mention the most outrageous mistake by our friends and the soon to be defunct MSNBC. “Morning Joe”. The most boring program next to an infomercial. Now that our dear friend “Don Imus” not so insignificant RFD-TV is going to be carried on Comcast Cable in mid January. Morning Joe better look for a new job. The only bright spot on that program is Willy Geist. And I were him I would get out of MSNBC before he goes down with the ship.
Happy New Year Spud and keep up the great work.
Comment by Bruce — December 31, 2007 @ 2:40 pm
Well done, Spud.
But one question - Rick Sanchez, - hot?? Yikes!
Give me a break!
Comment by Cella — December 31, 2007 @ 2:47 pm
My dear friend: Great list! I compiled a few as well but yours is far more comprehensive. I MUST start back on that Dexedrine for my terminal ADD! Happy New Year!
Marty
Comment by Marty Davis — December 31, 2007 @ 3:10 pm
He was hot for a while. He has cooled off recently. Still on average, he’s exceeded expectations for CNN.
I don’t consider Morning Joe not hot. I don’t consider it hot either. But I do think it’s improved a lot since it first started when MSNBC was still in Secaucus.
Comment by Spud — December 31, 2007 @ 3:24 pm
Great list Spud, but what about Chris Matthews “coming out” as a full-time Giuliani shill (paid? unpaid?), and now as Rudy’s star fades, Chris moving over to hitch his “star” to McCain? And at the same time, turning “Hardball” into a psychotherapist’s dream, with his bizarre daily, unrelenting, hate-filled visceral Clinton attacks.
Comment by Dmuse — December 31, 2007 @ 3:53 pm
MSNBC is in trouble. They will not be around by the close of 2008. Their ratings go up with crime, it’s only a matter of time before they close up shop for the weekend, and then start chopping more hours of programming during the week. Olbermann will be the last man standing, all MSNBC talent will move over to the network, and once Bush is out of office, Olbermann’s ratings will tank since he will not have anyone to attack anymore… and at that point, they will move him over to NBC Sports, where he does a much, much better job, and he could actually do something that earns him the 4 million bucks they are paying him each year.
Comment by Nobody — December 31, 2007 @ 4:22 pm
Spud,
Thanks for introducing me to Chickaboomer.
The column today is side-splitting.
Particularly “People I’d Love To See
Disappear.”
Guess who makes the first spot on the list - our favorite “Tee Vee” star - Courtney Friel.
And I was just kidding about Rick Sanchez.
Though I find him unappealing, I know he has garnered attention from some viewers.
Comment by Cella — December 31, 2007 @ 4:59 pm
Great list!
I’m glad you finally included the Friel factor.
And to Ira: there are many men out there complaining, maybe not here, but I’ve seen a lot!
Comment by Sarah — December 31, 2007 @ 5:57 pm
Spud: One item that I didn’t see on your list were the three Presidential debates that produced controversy that extended beyond cable TV.
First was the MSNBC Democratic debate where Hillary couldn’t answer Tim Russert’s question about drivers’ licenses for illegal aliens. Then there was the Dem debate from Las Vegas on CNN that was packed with Hillary supporters in the audience. Finally the CNN GOP/You Tube debate that featured more than a few Dem plants masquerading as “average citizens” including that “don’t ask, don’t tell” Hillary supporter from Santa Rosa, California.
Sarah: I’m not necessarily a fan of Ms. Friel but I have to scratch my head at some of the hysterical mostly female comments that I read here. In the context of the most important what happenings in cable TV in 2007, Courtney is like a gnat on an elephant, she means nothing!
Comment by Ira — December 31, 2007 @ 7:48 pm
Debates always produce some sort of controversy. It goes with the territory…
Comment by Spud — December 31, 2007 @ 9:29 pm
spud could you of added, “the culture quiz” being added to the factor…in all honesty the worst thing you could add to a so called “news Program”
Comment by chris — January 1, 2008 @ 2:04 pm
Good list, Spud. You seem to have caught all the major highlights.
I would only add to the NOT HOT list all the constant on-air bad mouthing of the competition (the bashing of individual talking heads and networks as a whole).
Instead of the repeated dissing of their competition, it would do cable news shows good to spend more time covering the actual news with facts and informed guests. The competition bashing reeks of political partisanship, personal agendas and one-upmanship. Overall I feel the pettiness brings down the level of professionalism and integrity in cable news.
Comment by STP — January 2, 2008 @ 1:20 am
(sound of many many many hands clapping) Great list Spud!
Comment by Obama in 08! — January 2, 2008 @ 10:28 am